This study is a result of over 40 years involvement with middle eastern culture including 7 years residence in iran beginning with a fullbright scholarship to complete phd work in persian music which became a book entitled music and song in persia published by curzon press in london in 1999. Each claimed the bible was lost, altered, corrupted and unreliable. The mormon claim is proven false by a book called 39 changes to book of mormon by sandra tanner. Islam and mormonism both originate in the abrahamic tradition. Aug, 2017 both islam and mormonism see an end to history, which is moving in linear fashion toward a divinelydetermined goal. Nonie darwish i had the great blessing and opportunity to listen to a woman speak at my church this past weekend that once again proved to me the god i worship is mighty indeed. Both islam and mormonism use many biblical themes, narratives and personalities.
The eleventh annual uvu mormon studies conference will engage in a comparative exploration of islam and mormonism. Islam and mormonism have been compared to one another ever since the earliest origins of the latter in the nineteenth century, often by detractors of one. As all ancient religions have a modern equivalent, mormonism can justly be claimed to be the modern form of mohammedanism, and not incorrectly termed \the islam of america. A brief introduction that explains mormons and their beliefs. It contains a lot of brief, yet informative articles about different aspects of islam. This is a reproduction of a book published before 1923.
Islam and mormonism have been compared to one another ever since the earliest origins of the. Mormonism, islam, and the question of other religions. In islam, abraham is recognized as a prophet, patriarch and messenger, archetype of the perfect muslim, and reformer. Jul 14, 2016 my own upbringing in mormonism intimately acquainted me with the book of mormon at an early age. This is a lofty goal for a work which purports to offer the basics. The fundamental principles of our religion is the testimony of the apostles and prophets concerning jesus christ, that he died, was buried, and rose again the third day, and ascended up into heaven.
Islam is a monotheistic and abrahamic religion articulated by the quran, a book considered by its adherents to be the verbatim word of god and by the teachings and normative example of muhammad, considered by them to be the last prophet of god. The mormons reacted brilliantly to the musical satirising their faith, but something important is lost when we treat religions so differently writes. Each claimed to be illiterate or uneducated and used this as proof the book was inspired. Page 189 verily, verily, i say unto you, if a man marry a wife according to my word, and they are sealed by the holy spirit of promise according to mine appointment, and he or she shall commit any sin or transgression of the new and everlasting covenant whatever, and all manner of blasphemies, and if they commit no murder, wherein they shed innocent blood, yet they shall come forth in the. Mormon bread and water sacrament life after ministry.
Both islam and mormonism claim to restore the true worship of god. Islam is the second largest religion in the world after christianity, with about. While both tip their hats to the bible, each see gods word as insufficient by itself. Jun 03, 2019 mormonism is not the correct term for the church of jesus christ of latterday saints or its teachings and never was. Viewing muhammad from the understanding of the restored gospel provides greater knowledge of heavenly fathers love for his children in all nations. Mormonism is the predominant religious tradition of the latter day saint movement of restorationist christianity started by joseph. Nearly one out of every six people on earth today is muslim.
In the case of the book of mormon, since the plates are no longer available, the end result is the same as with the quran. Joseph smith claimed that the angel moroni came to him, and ultimately gave him the reformed egyptian texts that became the book of mormon. Its believers are found on all of the inhabited continents. Mohammedans believe the koran has remained unchanged since its creation, but science shows that this is a wrong belief. Scholars and practitioners will reflect on points of connection and contrast between two traditions that face challenges. For many years, members of the church were known as mormons by those who were not members. The four common patterns found in cults that watchman fellowship uses are illustrated in these two religions. But the quran draws heavily from the apocryphal books rather than the authoritative cannon of the bible. A founding prophet who received visits from an angel, leading to revelation o f a boo k of scripture. Mormonism and christianity have a complex theological, historical, and sociological relationship. The purpose of hira cumorah is to share to write about islam from a latterday saint perspective, as this is much needed in the read more. They primarily belong to the church of jesus christ of latterday saints, or lds, which is headquartered in salt lake city, utah, and has more than 15 million members worldwide. Along with christians, muslims believe that god created all that exists ex nihilo out of nothing. It is called the book of mormon because mormon was the last prophet to write in the book and he compiled the other prophets records together.
What are the similarities between mormonism and islam. The book of mormon was translated and published in 1830. Many other points of similarity between these systems have been noted by students, and the book of mormon has marked resemblance to the koran. Jun 11, 2009 whats different about islam and mormonism. They read the rest of the christian scripture and tradition through the lens of the revelation of their own prophet, either joseph smith or muhammad. Both were to restore the long lost faith as the one true religion. The two religions i will be exploring, which i am unfamiliar with, are islam and mormonism. While islam currently does not have a universally recognized caliphate, the idea of the caliph is still part of islamic ideology.
With islam, it is the mother book that resides in heaven with god. Mormons are a religious group that embrace concepts of christianity as well as revelations made by their founder, joseph smith. Religionfacts does not necessarily endorse the contents of these books. Romney, islam and mormonism today i read an article on mormon times that talked about dr. For muslims, the quran and the sunna traditions of muhammad. Meet one of the authors of the world religions and cults book series, and learn more about our upcoming world religions conference july 2427, 2017. Mormonism simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Islam, the faith of the muslims, is a major world religion. Thus islam ignored its one unique advantage over conventional judaism and christianity, the joyful.
But there are millions of good and sincere muslims in many countries who love god and family while practicing islam in a tolerant and positive manner. In addition to the book of mormon, mormons believe the doctrine and covenants to be a series of modernday revelation from god. Basic similarities between the islamic an d mormon faiths include, but are not limited to. The mormon sacred scripture also includes a book called the pearl of great price, which includes two lost books of the bible, a translation of the gospel of matthew, and the articles of faith. Mormonism tracing conflict between latterday saints and the when the latterday saints arrived in the salt lake valley in 1847, they had reason to hope theyd escaped conflict with the american government forever.
However, worth noting is that there are also significant differences between mormonism and islam. It is generally acknowledged that mormonism is similar to. The islamic claim is proven false by a book in arabic language called, making easy the readings of what has been sent down by muhammad fahd khaaruun. This website is for people of various faiths who seek to understand islam and muslims. As i matured, i learned that islam, mormonism, and freemasonry join at numerous points in their history, ideology and practice. The book might work well in the undergraduate religious studies classroom. Each claimed his new holy book was the most correct and perfect book on earth. This volume explores the relationship between a major world religion islam and what some scholars have called the newest world religion mormonism. The ignorance of an 1820s new york storyteller is born out in page after page of the book of mormon. However, whereas islam insists upon the eternity, complete oneness and uniqueness of god, mormonism asserts that the godhead is made up of three distinct beings, each of which is referred to as a god.
Jesus is one of three gods in the godhead in mormonism, where islam teaches only one god. Smith later translated these plates and called the new scripture the book of mormon. In particular, mormonism, he writes, excited my interest at an early age before all else because of the surprising analogy, extending even to the smallest details, between it and the fundamental drives, external forms, and historical development of islam. Muhammad claimed that this angel of light was gabriel. Mormonism is a christian restorationist religious movement that was founded by joseph smith. Comparing mormonism and islam watchman fellowship, georgia. The similarities between islam and mormonism are obvious. It includes articles on such topics as building bridges of understanding, the language of god, jerusalems role as a holy city, the evolving relationship between islam and mormonism, and artistry and aesthetics in mormon and iranian film. Nov 21, 2019 i really didnt want to answer this question because i personally find it a waste of time, but since the current answers given are not very good or biased, ill heed the call and take a crack at it. The journal of discourses jd is an important source of early mormon sermons in twentyseven volumes. What are the similarities and differences between mormonism. Below is a table with documentation from both mormon sources and islamic sources, categorized by similarities. In both cases, islam and mormonism see their religion as complete within itself. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study.
Islam and mormonism conceive of god rather differently. Islam vs mormonism by kirk grim the islamic faith is centered on the belief in one god and in arabic he is called allah. Islam is the second largest religion in the world after christianity, with about 1. Joseph smith told a story in the book of mormon that cannot be verified by history or archaeology. The book of mormon is a history of the doings of very fallible humans, while devotees of the koran disdain to attribute to it anything as banal as human history. Both books show that the copy of the book of mormon and the koran used today is. A book produced from their teachings claimed to be inspired by god. In mormonism, abraham is recognized as a prophet, patriarch and messenger of pure unadulterated gibberish the book of abraham bom. A collection of handselected books on mormonism, chosen on the basis of apparent usefulness and quality.
Mormons believe they renew covenants made at baptism by taking sacrament. There are not only many important similarities between islam and mormonism, but also significant differences. Leopold classic library is delighted to publish this classic book as part of our extensive collection. Mormonism differs from mainstream christianity for being nontrinitarian. Mormonism teaches people have the potential becoming gods where islam would deny that. Polygamy called plural marriage by mormons in the 19th century or the principle by modern fundamentalist practitioners of polygamy was practiced by leaders of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints lds church for more than half of the 19th century, and practiced publicly from 1852 to 1890 by between 20 and 30 percent of latterday saint families. There are more than 12 million mormons today, with a slight majority residing outside north america. Muhammad wrote the quran and smith wrote the book of mormon 6. Search for library items search for lists search for. But islam is a much larger religion, has a much larger history, and is ingrained into government in a way that would make utah look like it is run by godless heathens. In this article we will explain some of the mormon articles of faith and clarify the differences between then and mainstream christianity whilst also pointing out the vast differences between mormon concepts and the doctrines of islam.
Similarities between islam and mormonism truthforsaints. After the book of mormon was published, mormonism began to spread and grow rapidly. Both claimed that their new bible was based upon a record stored in heaven. Understanding the islammormonism connection charisma news. Both religions reject the bible as the sole and sufficient authority of faith. The mormon sacred scripture also includes a book called the pearl of great price, which includes two lost books of the bible, a translation of the gospel of.
My beloved grandfather, gregorius hans helland 18841964, was a freemason. Of course the data in this book hundred pct guarantees there is no doubt in it you probably know. Both religions subtract from jesus by saying he is less than eternal deity. Written by rphilli posted in columns, islam, mormonism tagged with cults, false religions, islam, lds church, mormonism, mormons, muslims 3 comments. Mormons believe children taking sacrament is good practice for oaths theyll take in the future. Michael youssef, an egyptian american pastor who wrote an article on the similarities between islam and mormonism.
Description this compilation of groundbreaking articles about mormon views on islam is selected from over fifty years of lds scholarship published by byu studies. Yet the two religions have many interesting similarities and parallels. In common with christians generally, mormons as a whole know little of islam and its adherents. Islam and mormonisma comparison church of jesus christ. Both have new sacred books book of mormon and the quran that they claim were revealed by inspiration. Under differences between mormonism and islam there is the point whereas mormonism has a hierarchical structure, culminating in a single president of the church, islam does not. Both claimed their holy book was the most correct and perfect book on earth. As part of our ongoing commitment to delivering value to the reader. The sacred books of the mormons organization and methods of the mormon church mormonism as a religion mormonism as a life missions among the mormons. Each religion sees its founder muhammad for islam, and joseph smith for mormonism as being a true prophet of god, called to reestablish the truths of these ancient theological belief systems that have been altered, corrupted, or lost. The one thing that the lds has over islam, is that the lds believes christ jesus is the son of god, unto which islam does not believe, and islam does not believe in the holy spirit. Mormonism and islam are very similar from how they were founded, the mechanics on how members are to conduct themselves, and what experiences in heaven are like.
To this common ground between muslims and mormons is added the fact that both muhammad and joseph smith are regarded by their respective adherents as instruments in the hand of god in revealing new scriptures, the quran and the book of mormon in each. Apologists for mormonism claim that such a complicated work from such a. However the mormon version is in no way acceptable to islam. The rage has come from mormon claims that the book of mormon. Apologists for islam claim that such a complicated work from such a young uneducated mohammad is proof of the qurans divine inspiration. Mormons believe the book of mormon has remained unchanged since its creation, but there have been many revisions. Mormons express the doctrines of mormonism using standard biblical terminology and have similar views about the nature of jesus atonement, bodily resurrection, and second coming as traditional christianity. Mormonism and islam both take a basic christian groundwork and then supplement it with the teaching of their respective prophets. Even as a child, i thought it was weird when people used the term.
Hira cumorah mormonism, islam, linguists and the near. Sexual activity should only occur between a man and a woman who are married. Mormonism is not just another religion within christianity the two are polar opposites of each other. A geographical territory associated with the faithfu l in is lam the arab penins ula, in morm onism the state of utah in the usa citation needed. Both say that their god is the only true god, that their religion is the only true religion, and salvation is by works. This is a magnificent book that can explain in simple terms, along with examples, of how islam treats modernism and to what extent islam favours modernism and where islam prohibits modernism. Youssefs article and the response by daniel petersen who is a professor on.
Welcome to hira cumorah, the only website that is dedicated to the studies of mormonism and islam, and how these two remarkable faiths have impacted, and continue to impact the world. So close, yet so far away what should we make of claims that the two faiths are on a path to reconciling. There are many prophecies about the last days in both faiths, and these. Both men wrote a book that contained their secret revelations.
Mormonism and islam and america life after ministry. Islam and mormonism both originate in the abrahamic traditions. This compilation of groundbreaking articles about mormon views on islam is selected from over fifty years of lds scholarship published by byu studies. Bruce kinney the title of this, the latest of the textbooks issued by the council of women for home missions, may need a word of explanation. It also includes the book of mormon bom which joseph smith declared is the most correct of any book on earth, and the keystone of our religion, and a man would get nearer to god by abiding by its precepts, than by any other book teachings of the prophet joseph smith, p. For mormons, the book of mormon and other writings of the latter day saints represent gods final revelation. When it comes to the issue of samesex marriage, to its credit the church of jesus christ of latterday saints says, the churchs doctrinal position is clear. This book will open the eyes of the sincere seeker of truth and will show the differences between mormonism, islam and christianity. The book of mormon was also written in isolation and it too bears the mark of that isolation. From polemics to mutual respect and cooperation author arnold h. The islam of america claims, it is generally acknowledged that mormonism is similar to mohammedanism in its endorsement of the practice of polygamy, and its idea of heaven. Leopold classic library is delighted to publish this. Looking at a book can help persons out of this uncertainty information especially this mormonism, the islam of america primary source edition book because book offers you rich details and knowledge.
Meet one of the authors of the world religions and cults book series, and learn more about our upcoming world religions conference july. Jan 26, 2020 mormonism shares many common points of reference with christianity, more so than bahai faith and islam, but similar to them, it cannot be considered christianity in the classical and historic sense of the word. Islam and mormonism may not initially seem comparable, but the comparison is actually not new, going back to a few years after the founding of the lds church in. The muslims, followers of islam, believe that muhammad was visited by an angel of light from whom he received gods final revelation.
Islam makes claim that adam and abraham were muslims, a claim that is as ridiculous as it is undocumented from either history or archaeology. Green the worlds fastest growing religion is either islam if considering annual growth in total numbers or mormonism if considering annual growth in percentage terms. Jan 23, 2011 islam vs mormonism by kirk grim the islamic faith is centered on the belief in one god and in arabic he is called allah. Both mormonism and islam add to the word of god with the book of mormon, etc. Stephen prothero was one of two keynote speakers for the 11th annual mormon studies conference held at utah valley university on march 8th and 9th, 2011. Many of the prophets teachings in the book of mormon help to clarify the teachings in the bible that have otherwise been lost or distorted. All are available for purchase on click book images for details. A book entitled, mormonism, americas islam by bruce kinney gives us a list of some of the similarities between muhammad and joseph smith. Religious identity is defined mainly around how a religion defines god. Mormons make the unsubstantiated claim that the church in the first century were mormon. With mormonism, it is the golden nephi plates that the angel moroni took back to heaven. Was sent to restore the long lost faith as the one true religion.
546 7 716 1347 879 331 1012 1301 1457 1166 109 839 905 224 1230 452 197 900 1027 318 1083 855 1311 482 555 20 176 791 1089 557 1066 1061 275 598 181 809 182 1344 1491 40 439 1132 973